Effects of Silicon and Zinc Fertilizer and Their Application Ways on Yield and Grain Quality of Rice Variety Nanjing 46

doi:10.16819/j.1001-7216.2023.220805

Abstract

Abstract:

【Objective】It is important to clarify the effects of silicon and zinc fertilizer and their application methods on rice quality and grain yield of Nanjing 46.【Method】Nine fertilizer application treatments were designed, including soil topdressing of silicon fertilizer (Si-B), soil topdressing of zinc fertilizer (Zn-B), soil topdressing of silicon fertilizer + foliar spraying of silicon fertilizer (Si-B+Si-L), soil topdressing of zinc fertilizer + foliar spraying of zinc fertilizer (Zn-B+Zn-L), soil topdressing of silicon fertilizer + soil topdressing of zinc fertilizer (Si-B+Zn-B), foliar spraying of silicon fertilizer (Si-L), foliar spraying of zinc fertilizer (Zn-L), foliar spraying of silicon fertilizer + foliar spraying of zinc fertilizer (Si-L+Zn-L), and no silicon and zinc fertilizer application (CK). The soil topdressing was conducted during last 4-leaf stage and the foliar spraying was conducted during the booting stage (5－7 days before heading). We evaluated the effects of different treatments on the grain yield and its components, processing quality, appearance quality, eating quality and the 2-acetyl-1-pyrroline (2-AP) content of Nanjing 46.【Result】The silicon and zinc fertilizer application obviously increased grain yield of Nanjing 46 with the increasing range of 0.8－11.9%, which resulted from the increase of 1000-grain weight and the number of grains per panicle. The silicon fertilizer application decreased the rates of brown rice and milled rice, while the zinc fertilizer increased the rates of brown rice and milled rice. The silicon and zinc fertilizers could increase the head rice rate, with the latter being more influential. The effects of silicon and zinc fertilizers on the amylose content and RVA profile values varied with treatments, but the silicon and zinc fertilizers could increase the breakdown viscosity, reduce the setback viscosity, increase the gel consistency, the 2-AP content and aroma, improve the taste value.【Conclusion】Soil topdressing of silicon fertilizer and foliar spraying of zinc fertilizer could increase not only the grain yield, but also the head rice rate, aroma and eating quality of Nanjing 46.

Key words: rice, silicon fertilizer, zinc fertilizer, yield, rice quality

摘要：

【目的】比较硅锌肥及其施用方式对南粳46稻米产量和品质的影响，为调优栽培提供参考依据。【方法】以优良食味粳稻品种南粳46为材料，倒4叶期土壤追施和孕穗期(抽穗前5~7 d)叶面喷施硅肥和锌肥，设置土壤追施硅肥(Si-B)、土壤追施锌肥(Zn-B)、土壤追施硅肥+叶面喷施硅肥(Si-B+Si-L)、土壤追施锌肥+叶面喷施锌肥(Zn-B+Zn-L)、土壤追施硅肥+土壤追施锌肥(Si-B+Zn-B)、叶面喷施硅肥(Si-L)、叶面喷施锌肥(Zn-L)、叶面喷施硅肥+叶面喷施锌肥(Si-L+Zn-L)8个处理，以不施硅锌肥(CK)为对照，调查分析不同处理对南粳46籽粒产量及其构成因素、加工品质、外观品质、食味品质和香味物质2-乙酰-1-吡咯啉(2-AP)含量的影响。【结果】施用硅锌肥对南粳46均有明显的增产作用，增幅为0.8%~11.9%，增产的原因主要是增加了每穗粒数和千粒重，而对穗数和结实率没有明显影响。施用硅肥使糙米率和精米率下降，施用锌肥则使糙米率和精米率增加，施用硅肥和锌肥都可使整精米率提高，施用锌肥提高整精米率的效果比施用硅肥更明显。硅锌肥对直链淀粉含量和RVA特征值的影响随处理不同而异，但施用硅锌肥可以提高崩解值，降低消减值，使胶稠度显著增加，食味值明显提高，稻米2-AP含量显著增加，香味明显变浓。【结论】倒4叶期土壤追施硅肥与孕穗期叶面喷施锌肥相结合，既可增加南粳46的产量，又能提高整精米率和食味品质，增加香味。

关键词: 水稻, 硅肥, 锌肥, 产量, 品质

WEI Xiaodong, SONG Xuemei, ZHAO Ling, ZHAO Qingyong, CHEN Tao, LU Kai, ZHU Zhen, HUANG Shengdong, WANG Cailin, ZHANG Yadong. Effects of Silicon and Zinc Fertilizer and Their Application Ways on Yield and Grain Quality of Rice Variety Nanjing 46[J]. Chinese Journal OF Rice Science, 2023, 37(3): 295-306.

魏晓东, 宋雪梅, 赵凌, 赵庆勇, 陈涛, 路凯, 朱镇, 黄胜东, 王才林, 张亚东. 硅锌肥及其施用方式对南粳46产量和稻米品质的影响[J]. 中国水稻科学, 2023, 37(3): 295-306.

Figures/Tables 12

References 42

[1]	戴青云, 刘代欢, 王德新, 李鹏祥, 朱维, 桂娟. 硅对水稻生长的影响及其缓解镉毒害机理研究进展[J]. 中国农学通报, 2020, 36(5): 86-92.
	Dai Q Y, Liu D H, Wang D X, Li P X, Zhu W, Gui J. A review on silicon: Effect on rice growth and its mechanism of relieving cadmium toxicity[J]. Chinese Agricultural Science Bulletin, 2020, 36(5): 86-92. (in Chinese with English abstract)
[2]	黄彬, 韩永圣, 秦政. 硅素的肥料效应及补硅途径[J]. 江苏农业科学, 1997(3): 47-49.
	Huang B, Han Y S, Qin Z. Fertilizer effect of silicon and ways of silicon supplement[J]. Jiangsu Agricultural Sciences, 1997(3): 47-49. (in Chinese)
[3]	许佳莹, 朱练峰, 禹盛苗, 张均华, 金千瑜. 硅肥对水稻产量及生理特性影响的研究进展[J]. 中国稻米, 2012, 18(6): 18-22.
	Xu J Y, Zhu L F, Yu S M, Zhang J H, Jin Q Y. Research progress on the effects of silicon fertilizer on rice yield and physiological characteristics[J]. China Rice, 2012, 18 (6): 18-22. (in Chinese)
[4]	张岩, 宋玉霞, 陈虞超, 石磊. 硅元素对水稻生长的影响概述[J]. 宁夏农林科技, 2010(6): 85-88.
	Zhang Y, Song Y X, Chen Y C, Shi L. Effects of silicon on rice growth[J]. Ningxia Agriculture and Forestry Science and Technology, 2010(6): 85-88. (in Chinese)
[5]	杨波, 靳辉勇, 屠乃美, 田茂成, 田丰, 周伟, 李栋宇. 锌肥在水稻上的应用研究进展[J]. 天津农业科学, 2018, 24(3): 47-50, 58.
	Yang B, Jin H Y, Tu N M, Tian M C, Tian F, Zhou W, Li D Y. Progress of researches on Zinc fertilizer application in rice[J]. Tianjin Agricultural Sciences, 2018, 24(3): 47-50, 58. (in Chinese with English abstract)
[6]	Alvarez J, Datnoff L E. The Economic potential of silicon for integrated management and sustainable rice production[J]. Crop Protection, 2001, 20: 43-48.
[7]	丁能飞, 郭彬, 李建强, 林义成, 刘琛, 李华, 李凝玉, 傅庆林. 氮硅互作对水稻营养和产量的影响[J]. 中国农学通报, 2013, 29: 127-130.
	Ding N F, Guo B, Li J Q, Lin Y C, Liu C, Li H, Li N Y, Fu Q L. Effects of nitrogen and silicon interaction on the nutrition and yield of rice[J]. Bulletin of Chinese Agronomy, 2013, 29: 127-130. (in Chinese with English abstract)
[8]	张国良, 戴其根, 王建武, 张洪程, 霍中洋, 凌励, 王显, 张军. 施硅量对粳稻品种武育粳3号产量和品质的影响[J]. 中国水稻科学, 2007, 21(3): 299-303.
	Zhang G L, Dai Q G, Wang J W, Zhang H C, Huo Z Y, Ling L, Wang Y, Zhang J. Effects of silicon fertilizer rate on yield and quality of japonica rice Wuyujing 3[J]. Chinese Journal of Rice Science, 2007, 21(3): 299-303. (in Chinese with English abstract)
[9]	邓接楼, 王艾平, 何长水, 王爱斌, 徐芬芬. 硅肥对水稻生长发育及产量品质的影响[J]. 广东农业科学, 2011(12): 58-61.
	Deng J L, Wang A P, He C S, Wang A B, Xu F F. The effect of Si fertilizer on growth and development, yield and quality of rice[J]. Guangdong Agricultural Sciences, 2011(12): 58-61. (in Chinese with English abstract)
[10]	Luo H W, Du B, He L X, He J, Hu L, Pan S G, Tang X R. Exogenous application of zinc (Zn) at the heading stage regulates 2-acetyl-1-pyrroline(2-AP) biosynthesis in different fragrant rice genotypes[J]. Scientific Reports, 2019 (9): 19513.
[11]	Mo Z W, Lei S, Umair A, Imran K, Li Y, Pan S G, Duan M Y, Tian H, Tang X R. Silicon fertilization modulates 2-acetyl-1-pyrroline content, yield formation and grain quality of aromatic rice[J]. Journal of Cereal Science, 2017, 75: 17-24.
[12]	高丹, 陈基宁, 蔡昆争, 骆世明. 硅在植物体内的分布和吸收及其在病害逆境胁迫中的抗性作用[J]. 生态学报, 2010, 30: 2745-2755.
	Gao D, Chen J N, Cai K Z, Luo S M. Distribution and absorption of Si in plant and its role in plant disease resistance under environmental stress[J]. Acta Ecologica Sinica, 2010, 30: 2745-2755. (in Chinese with English abstract)
[13]	薛高峰, 孙万春, 宋阿琳, 李兆君, 范分良, 梁永超. 硅对水稻生长、白叶枯病抗性及病程相关蛋白活性的影响[J]. 中国农业科学, 2010, 43(4): 690-697.
	Xue G F, Sun W C, Song A L, Li Z J, Fan F L, Liang Y C. Influence of Si on rice growth, resistance to bacterial blight and activity of pathogenesis-related proteins[J]. Scientia Agricultura Sinica, 2010, 43(4): 690-697. (in Chinese with English abstract)
[14]	王力, 孙影, 张洪程, 魏海燕, 朱大伟, 朱盈, 徐栋, 霍中洋. 不同时期施用锌硅肥对优良食味粳稻产量和品质的影响[J]. 作物学报, 2017, 43(6): 885-898.
	Wang L, Sun Y, Zhang H C, Wei H Y, Zhu D W, Zhu Y, Xu D, Huo Z Y. Effect of Zn and Si fertilizers applied at different stages on yield and quality of japonica rice with good eating quality[J]. Acta Agronomica Sinica, 2017, 43(6): 885-898. (in Chinese with English abstract)
[15]	黄锦霞, 肖迪, 段美洋, 田华, 黎国喜, 钟克友, 唐湘如. 不同锌肥施用量对香稻产量和糙米香气含量的影响[J]. 华北农学报, 2008, 23(S2): 290-292.
	Huang J X, Xiao D, Duan M Y, Tian H, Li G X, Zhong K Y, Tang X R. Effects of different applications of ZnCl₂ on the yield and aroma content of aromatic rice[J]. Acta Agriculturae Boreali-Sinica, 2008, 23(S2): 290-292. (in Chinese with English abstract)
[16]	黄锦霞, 肖迪, 唐湘如. 施锌对香稻产量、香气和品质的影响[J]. 耕作与栽培, 2010(3): 5-7.
	Huang J X, Xiao D, Tang X R. Effects of zinc application on yield, aroma and quality of fragrant rice[J]. Tillage and Cultivation, 2010 (3): 5-7. (in Chinese)
[17]	Liu X W, Huang Z L, Li Y H, Xie W J, Li W, Tang X R, Ashraf U, Kong L L, Wu L M, Wang S L, Mo Z W. Selenium-silicon (Se-Si) induced modulations in physio-biochemical responses, grain yield, quality, aroma formation and lodging in fragrant rice[J]. Ecotoxicology and Environmental Safety, 2020, 196: 110525.
[18]	李军, 邓先亮, 朱兴敏, 郭保卫, 魏海燕, 张洪程. 镁锌肥施用时期对优质软米粳稻产量及稻米中6种元素吸收的影响[J]. 中国稻米, 2018, 24(4): 57-63.
	Li J, Deng X L, Zhu X M, Guo B W, Wei H Y, Zhang H C. Effects of magnesium and zinc microelement fertilizer on the yield and accumulation of six elements of japonica rice[J]. China Rice, 2018, 24(4): 57-63. (in Chinese with English abstract)
[19]	张磊, 陈雪丽, 李伟群, 常本超, 王爽, 谷学佳, 王晓军, 王玉峰, 王英. 叶喷式高效硅肥对水稻产量和品质的影响[J]. 现代化农业, 2014(11): 12-13.
	Zhang L, Chen X L, Li W Q, Chang B C, Wang S, Gu X J, Wang X J, Wang Y F, Wang Y. Effects of leaf spraying high efficiency silicon fertilizer on yield and quality of rice[J]. Modernizing Agriculture, 2014(11): 12-13. (in Chinese with English abstract)
[20]	王才林, 张亚东, 朱镇, 赵凌, 陈涛, 林静. 优质水稻新品种南粳46的选育与应用[J]. 中国稻米, 2008(3): 38-40.
	Wang C L, Zhang Y D, Zhu Z, Zhao L, Chen T, Lin J. Breeding and utilization of new rice variety Nanjing 46 with good eating quality[J]. China Rice, 2008(3): 38-40. (in Chinese with English abstract)
[21]	王才林, 张亚东, 赵春芳, 魏晓东, 姚姝, 周丽慧, 朱镇, 陈涛, 赵庆勇, 赵凌, 路凯, 梁文化. 江苏省优良食味粳稻的遗传与育种研究[J]. 遗传, 2021, 43(5): 442-458.
	Wang C L, Zhang Y D, Zhao C F, Wei X D, Yao S, Zhou L H, Zhu Z, Chen T, Zhao Q Y, Zhao L, Lu K, Liang W H. Inheritance and breeding of japonicarice with good eating quality in Jiangsu Province, 2021, 43 (5): 442-458. (in Chinese with English abstract)
[22]	莫惠栋. 农业试验统计[M]. 上海: 上海科学技术出版社, 1992: 151-166.
	Mo H D. Agricultural Experiment Statistics[M]. Shanghai: Shanghai Science and Technology Press, 1992: 151-166. (in Chinese)
[23]	殷碧秋, 常红, 齐君. 硅肥对水稻品质的影响及发展前景[J]. 吉林农业, 2010(5): 112.
	Yin B Q, Chang H, Qi J. Effect of silicon fertilizer on rice quality and its development prospect[J]. Jilin Agriculture, 2010 (5): 112. (in Chinese with English abstract)
[24]	陈平平. 硅在水稻生活中的作用[J]. 生物学通报, 1998, 33(8): 5-7.
	Chen P P. Role of silicon in rice life[J]. Bulletin of Biology, 1998, 33(8): 5-7. (in Chinese with English abstract)
[25]	赵海成, 李红宇, 陈立强, 赫臣, 郑桂萍, 韩笑, 何文翠, 周云峰. 硅氮配施对寒地水稻产量品质及抗倒性的影响[J]. 上海农业学报, 2018, 34(4): 36-42.
	Zhao H C, Li H Y, Chen L Q, He C, Zhen G P, Han X, He W C, Zhou Y F. Effects of combined application of silicon and nitrogen on yield and lodging resistance of cold-region rice[J]. Acta Agriculturae Shanghai, 2018, 34(4): 36-42. (in Chinese with English abstract)
[26]	陈光东, 杨新彬, 董广林. 硅肥对水稻的增产及抗瘟效应[J]. 农村实用科技信息, 2006(6): 9.
	Chen G D, Yang X B, Dong G L. Effects of silicon fertilizer on yield increase and blast resistance of rice[J]. Rural Practical Science and Technology Information, 2006 (6): 9. (in Chinese)
[27]	Mathpal B, Srivastava P C, Shankhdhar D. Improving key enzyme activities and quality of rice under various methods of zinc application[J]. Physiology and Molecular Biology of Plants, 2015, 21(4): 567-572.
[28]	张凯岳. 锌对水稻碳酸酐酶和光合作用的调节作用研究[D]. 武汉: 华中农业大学, 2015.
	Zhang K Y. Regulation of zinc on carbonic anhydrase and photosynthesis in rice[D]. Wuhan: Huazhong Agricultural University, 2015. (in Chinese with English abstract)
[29]	周青, 潘国庆, 施作家, 陈风华. 不同时期施用硅肥对水稻群体产量及产量的影响[J]. 耕作与栽培, 2001(3): 25-27.
	Zhou Q, Pan G Q, Shi Z J, Chen F H. Effect of application of Si on populication quality and yield of rice at different periods[J]. Tillage and Cultivation, 2001(3): 25-27. (in Chinese with English abstract)
[30]	张国良, 戴其根, 周青, 潘国庆, 凌励, 张洪程. 硅肥对水稻群体质量及产量影响研究[J]. 中国农学通报, 2004(4): 114-117.
	Zhang G L, Dai Q G, Zhou Q. Influences of Si fertilizer on population quality and yield in rice[J]. Bulletin of Chinese Agronomy, 2004(4): 114-117. (in Chinese with English abstract)
[31]	宋合林, 刘兵, 崔占文, 田强. 不同生育时期施用硅肥对水稻产量的影响[J]. 现代化农业, 2009(9): 18.
	Song H L, Liu B, Cui Z W, Tian Q. Effect of application of Si on yield of rice at different periods[J]. Modernizing Agriculture, 2009(9): 18. (in Chinese with English abstract)
[32]	龚金龙, 胡雅杰, 龙厚元, 常勇, 葛梦婕, 高辉, 刘艳阳, 张洪程, 戴其根, 霍中洋, 许轲, 魏海燕, 李德剑, 沙安勤, 周有炎, 罗学超. 不同时期施硅对超级稻产量和硅素吸收、利用效率的影响[J]. 中国农业科学, 2012, 45(8): 1475-1488.
	Gong J L, Hu Y J, Long H Y, Chang Y, Ge M J, Gao H, Liu Y Y, Zhang H C, Dai Q G, Huo Z Y, Xu K, Wei H Y, Li D J, Sha A Q, Zhou Y Y, Luo X C. Effect of application of Si at different periods on grain yield and Si absorption, use efficiency in super rice[J]. Scientia Agricultura Sinica, 2012, 45(8): 1475-1488. (in Chinese with English abstract)
[33]	张珍淑, 漆光成, 杨培权, 蒋明艳. 基施锌肥对水稻产量影响试验初探[J]. 安徽农学通报, 2014(6): 84-85.
	Zhang Z S, Qi G C, Yang P Q, Jiang M Y. The first exploring experiment the efficiency on yield of rice with basal Zn fertilizers[J]. Anhui Agricultural Science Bulletin, 2014(6): 84-85. (in Chinese with English abstract)
[34]	阮洪家, 胡敬年, 叶为发, 马俊飞. 施用硅肥对水稻生育特性及产量的影响[J]. 现代农业科技, 2015(3): 9-10.
	Ruan H J, Hu J N, Ye W F, Ma J F. Effect of application of Si on growth characters and yield of rice[J]. Modern Agricultural Science and Technology, 2015(3): 9-10. (in Chinese with English abstract)
[35]	韦还和, 孟天瑶, 李超, 张洪程, 史天宇, 马荣荣, 王晓燕, 杨筠文, 戴其根, 霍中洋, 许轲, 魏海燕, 郭保卫. 施硅量对甬优系列籼粳交超级稻产量及相关形态生理性状的影响[J]. 作物学报, 2016, 42(3): 437-445.
	Wei H H, Meng T Y, Li C, Zhang H C, Shi T Y, Ma R R, Wang X Y, Yang J W, Dai Q G, Huo Z Y, Xu K, Wei H Y, Guo B W. Effects of Si fertilizer rate on grain yield and related morphological and physiological characteristics in super rice of Yongyou japonica-indica hybrids series[J]. Acta Agronomica Sinica, 2016, 42(3): 437-445. (in Chinese with English abstract)
[36]	Liu X W, Huang Z L, Li Y Z, Xie W J, Li W, Tang X R, Ashraf U, Kong L L, Wu L M, Wang S L, Mo Z W. Selenium-silicon (Se-Si) induced modulations in physio-biochemical responses, grain yield, quality, aroma formation and lodging in fragrant rice[J]. Ecotoxicology and Environmental Safety, 2020, 196 (15): 110525.
[37]	马朝红, 汪应城, 陈家贵, 黄学富, 王乾璋. 硅、锌肥配合施用对水稻生长和产量的影响[J]. 湖北农业科学, 2014, 53 (24): 5956-5958.
	Ma C H, Wang Y C, Chen J G, Huang X F, Wang Q Z. Effects of applying Si fertilizer combined with Zn fertilizer on the growth and grain yield of rice[J]. Hubei Agricultural Sciences, 2014, 53(24): 5956-5958. (in Chinese with English abstract)
[38]	张国良. 硅肥对水稻产量和品质的影响及硅对水稻纹枯病抗性的初步研究[D]. 扬州: 扬州大学, 2005.
	Zhang G L. Effects of silicon fertilizer on rice yield and quality and resistance to rice sheath blight[D]. Yangzhou: Yangzhou University, 2005. (in Chinese with English abstract)
[39]	商全玉, 张文忠, 韩亚东, 荣蓉, 徐海, 徐正进, 陈温福. 硅肥对北方粳稻产量和品质的影响[J]. 中国水稻科学, 2009, 23(6): 661-664.
	Shang Q Y, Zhang W Z, Han Y D, Rong R, Xu H, Xu Z J, Chen W F. Effect of silicon fertilizer application on yield and grain quality of japonica rice from northeast China[J]. Chinease Journal of Rice Science, 2009, 23 (6): 661-664. (in Chinese with English abstract)
[40]	唐湘如, 吴密. 施用锌、铁、镧肥对香稻米质和产量的影响[J]. 杂交水稻, 2007, 22(2): 69-72.
	Tang X R, Wu M. Effects of zinc, iron and lanthanum on rice quality and yield of fragrant rice[J]. Hybrid Rice, 2007, 22(2): 69-72. (in Chinese with English abstract)
[41]	王远敏. 硅对水稻生长发育及产量品质的影响研究[D]. 重庆: 西南大学, 2007.
	Wang Y M. Effects of silicon on growth, yield and quality of rice[D]. Chongqing: Southwest University, 2007. (in Chinese with English abstract)
[42]	丁王梅. 纳米硅制剂对水稻养分吸收及品质的影响[D]. 沈阳: 东北农业大学, 2015.
	Ding W M. Effects of nano silicon preparation on nutrient absorption and quality of rice[D]. Shenyang: Northeast Agricultural University, 2015. (in Chinese with English abstract)

变异来源 Source of variance	自由度 df	穗数 PN	每穗粒数 NSP	结实率 SSR/%	千粒重 GW/g	产量 GY
重复Repetition	2	1.87	0.62	0.78	0.23	0.86
年份 Year	1	2.48	0.44	0.01	0.52	1.66
处理Treatment	8	1.84	4.35^**	0.93	8.04^**	8.10^**
年份×处理 Year×Treatment	8	0.94	1.28	0.65	1.07	0.98

变异来源 Source of variance	自由度 df	穗数 PN	每穗粒数 NSP	结实率 SSR/%	千粒重 GW/g	产量 GY
重复Repetition	2	1.87	0.62	0.78	0.23	0.86
年份 Year	1	2.48	0.44	0.01	0.52	1.66
处理Treatment	8	1.84	4.35^**	0.93	8.04^**	8.10^**
年份×处理 Year×Treatment	8	0.94	1.28	0.65	1.07	0.98

处理 Treatment	穗数 PN/(×10⁴·hm^-2)	每穗粒数 NSP	千粒重 GW/g	结实率 SSR/%	产量 GY/(kg·hm^-2)
CK	410.5	125.7 c	25.7 b	93.4	8656.3 d
Si-B	376.3	136.0 b	26.6 b	94.2	8966.3 bcd
Si-L	401.9	123.7 c	25.6 b	93.9	8840.9 cd
Zn-B	410.5	117.2 c	26.3 b	93.7	8728.6 d
Zn-L	350.6	142.0 b	26.5 b	93.3	8848.4 cd
Si-B+Si-L	367.7	146.2 ab	27.8 a	95.5	9682.6 a
Zn-B+Zn-L	359.2	153.9 a	25.6 b	93.2	9085.0 abcd
Si-B+Zn-B	367.7	141.6 b	26.4 b	94.8	9548.0 ab
Si-L+Zn-L	359.2	150.3 a	26.2 b	94.0	9364.3 abc

处理 Treatment	穗数 PN/(×10⁴·hm^-2)	每穗粒数 NSP	千粒重 GW/g	结实率 SSR/%	产量 GY/(kg·hm^-2)
CK	410.5	125.7 c	25.7 b	93.4	8656.3 d
Si-B	376.3	136.0 b	26.6 b	94.2	8966.3 bcd
Si-L	401.9	123.7 c	25.6 b	93.9	8840.9 cd
Zn-B	410.5	117.2 c	26.3 b	93.7	8728.6 d
Zn-L	350.6	142.0 b	26.5 b	93.3	8848.4 cd
Si-B+Si-L	367.7	146.2 ab	27.8 a	95.5	9682.6 a
Zn-B+Zn-L	359.2	153.9 a	25.6 b	93.2	9085.0 abcd
Si-B+Zn-B	367.7	141.6 b	26.4 b	94.8	9548.0 ab
Si-L+Zn-L	359.2	150.3 a	26.2 b	94.0	9364.3 abc

处理比较 Comparison between treatments	每穗粒数 NSP	千粒重 GW/g	产量 GY/(kg·hm^-2)
Si-Zn－0Si-Zn	13.2^*	0.6	476.7^*
Si－Zn	−2.4	0.6	275.9
Si-B－Zn-B	18.8^**	0.3	237.7
Si-L－Zn-L	−18.3^**	−0.8^*	−7.5
(Si-B+Si-L)－(Zn-B+Zn-L)	−7.7^*	2.2^**	597.6^**
B－L	−7.0^*	0.4	63.1
Si-B－Si-L	12.3^*	1.0^*	125.4
Zn-B－Zn-L	−24.8^**	−0.1	−119.8
(Si-B+Zn-B)－(Si-L+Zn-L)	−8.6^*	0.3	183.7